QUOTE(peregrine @ Feb 27 2009, 12:17 PM)

I'm in the Great Horned Owl camp, based on the witness descriptions. The tracks seen on the roof and the distance between them could be explained easily enough, it seems to me, as being made by an owl that was hopping, which is one way owls get around.
The main thing that disappointed me was the inclusion of the stupid "Montauk Monster" in the show.
Totally agree!
It seemed to me that the Montauk Monster bit was a lame attempt to fill a time gap in an episode where there was not enough material ( evidence) to fill an actual 1 hour time slot...
I would vote owl as well.