This is one I learned about last year. I live about twenty minutes away from Churubusco.
The following is taken from Northern Indiana Perspective.
By GARY KAUFFMAN
Aside from Godzilla, few animals have made an impact on a town the way Oscar did on Churubusco.
Oscar, you might guess, was something fierce, like a grizzly bear, a wolverine or at least a Doberman Pinscher. But take a drive through the little town of Churubusco and you'll quickly realize that Oscar was a turtle.
In fact, Churubusco is obsessed with the turtle motif ‚š€š a turtle guards the entrance to the park, adorns the town's letterhead and is popularized on the signs of many businesses.
But Oscar wasn't some box turtle you might crush on the highway. Oscar was the Godzilla of turtles, a turtle known as The Beast of Busco.
Churubusco, located 15 miles north of Fort Wayne, boasts a population of 1,800. In an odd twist of fate, the Indian chief who lived in the area when the first white settler came was named Little Turtle. A post office made Churubusco an official town in 1847. But for the first 100 years of its existence 'Busco was virtually unknown. Then Oscar came to town.
Reports claimed Oscar's shell could have been used as a dining room table. His neck was likened to a stove pipe and his head was the size of a child's.
"One report said it was as big as the top of a car, and in the 1940s, the top of a car was pretty good sized," says Chuck Mathieu, president of the Churubusco town council and manager of Egolf's IGA. Mathieu was alive then, but just barely, so he never saw Oscar.
The trouble was, the number of people who didn't see Oscar greatly outnumbered those who did. Of the people who saw The Beast of Busco, only one man was sure of what he'd seen. That man was Gale Harris, who owned the property containing Fulk Lake, which Oscar called home.
Some people weren't sure about Harris' report of this enormous turtle; many others simply ridiculed him. In March 1949, Harris launched a massive effort to track down the beast and display him to the world.
"He wanted to prove to people that he hadn't imagined it," says Viv Rosswurm, managing editor of the Churubusco News.
The search began during a lull in major news. Editors across the nation latched onto the story, splashing the search in headlines from coast to coast. Soon people in New York and Chicago were as interested in Harris' search as the people in Churubusco.
Ultimately, illness and bad luck forced Harris to call off his search before finding Oscar. The turtle was never seen again. But far from dying away, the legend of Oscar grew. Probably more people believe in Oscar now than did in 1949.
"I think most of them want to believe," Mathieu says. "They think there was something there, although it may not have been the actual size. I'm sure as the years have gone on, the turtle has grown."
Rosswurm knows the people of Churubusco believe in Oscar. "Especially the old timers. They all knew somebody who saw it. They're pretty protective about the fact that it was real."
There are even some new theories about the giant turtle. "There are those who think it was a hoax," Rosswurm says. "But you probably won't find them in Churubusco."
Churubusco quickly latched onto the turtle theme, starting the Turtle Days Festival in 1950. It is still celebrated every June. Turtle Days has all the traditional features such as rides, games, food stands, a merchants tent, a parade and entertainment every night. But the highlight is the Turtle Races, a four-hour event as turtle after turtle is eliminated until one emerges as a winner. These turtles, though, are the size of a dessert plate, not a dining room table. Merchants also recognized a good thing when they saw it.
Even today, a shopping mall is called Turtle Town Plaza. A car dealership goes by the name Oscar's Autos, with a picture of a turtle. Even the town government adorns its official logo with a picture of a happy turtle.
"The town did balk, though, about naming the school team the ‚š€œSnappers' or ‚š€œTurtles,'" Rosswurm says. Instead, they became the Churubusco Eagles. An eagle is the most important symbol of the United States, stirring feelings national pride. But in Churubusco, it is nothing compared to the turtle.
There are more stories about oscar here.
http://www.churubusco.net/ click on the turtle days link.