Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Evolution Of Discovery
Bigfoot Forums > Bigfoot/Sasquatch Discussion > Research & Investigation
Huntster
I believe that the discovery of the gorilla (coincidentally occurring at the precise era when Darwin published "Origin of Species") has many similarities to the sasquatch phenomenon.

I found an interesting plug on a book series.

http://www.sc.edu/library/spcoll/nathist/darwin/darwin7.html

QUOTE
...A preemptive strike in the debate over development
Richard Owen,
"On the Anthropoid Apes,"
Report of the British Association, 33 (1854), part 2: 111-113.

The distinguished anatomist and palaeontologist Richard Owen, who had contributed to Darwin's Zoology of the Beagle, emerged during the 1850s as one of the leading opponents of secular biology. In 1849, a missionary oddly named Savage first reported the existence of a new primate, the gorilla, and Owen, seeing a potential threat to the distinctiveness of humans, obtained specimen gorilla skulls. By the mid-1850s, Wombwell's Menagerie was touring Britain with a live gorilla on display. In this address to the largely-amateur British Association, Owen took up a firm anti-Lamarckian stance, with no space for ideas of species transmutation. He subsequently asserted that the distinctiveness of humanity lay in a single portion of the brain, the hippocampus minor. While Owen would later become the butt of brutal attacks by the Darwinians, especially Huxley, his intransigence in the 1850s warned the still-cautious Darwin about the risks of discussing human evolution until his general theory was established.


(Note the "largely amatuer" label; where were the "scientists" then?)

The ideological struggle of Darwin was careful of is still, 150 years later, running hot worldwide. The discovery of the gorilla was as much fodder then as the discovery of sasquatch would be today.

I have read indications that Darwin had written things regarding DuChaillu's discovery. Paul DuChaillu was the Westerner who first acquired and delivered a gorilla specimen to British science, and there was much controversy and disbelief following DuChaillu's discovery. I am still looking for Darwin's written words. I would like to read what he had to say about the gorilla at that time.
Huntster
More on the discovery of the gorilla:

http://www.berggorilla.de/english/gjournal/texte/11men.html

QUOTE
Thomas Staughton Savage (1804-1880), Jeffries Wyman (1814-1874)

The American Thomas S. Savage was a protestant clergyman, missionary, physician and naturalist. In 1833 he received the degree of M. D. at Yale Medical School and then studied at a theological seminary. He was sent as a missionary to Liberia in 1836. While working in Africa, he showed great interest for the fauna of this continent.
When he finally went on his way back to America in 1847, he was detained in Gaboon. There he noticed the skull of a large great ape which belonged to the clergiman J. L. Wilson. Savage was able to acquire several more skulls and some bones from this, until then, unknown species. They were referred to as 'Engé-ena' by the local people, and he described them together with Jeffries Wyman with the scientific name Troglodytes gorilla. The species name 'gorilla' they adopted from the report of the Carthaginian seafarer Hanno (470 b. Chr.). He had called by this name hairy 'savage people' he had found on the western coast of Africa.
Savage wrote about these animals in his publication:
They are exceedingly ferocious, and always offensive in their habits, never running from man as does the Chimpanzée... The killing of an Engé-ena is considered an act of great skill and courage, and brings to the victor signal honor... They are generally eaten, and their flesh, with that of the Chimpanzée, and monkeys at large, occupies a prominent place in their 'bill of fare'...
The skull of the Engé-ena recedes much farther from the human type than that of the Enché-eco, in its greater development of the cranial crests and ridges, in the greater elongation of the upper jaw downwards and forwards, in the length of the bony palate, no less than in the much more brutal and ferocious expression of the face; in this last respect it even surpassses the Orangs of Borneo and Sumatra.
In addition, Savage studied African reptiles and insects. After returning to the USA, he continued to serve his church.
Jeffries Wyman, likewise an American, practiced medicine for three years in Boston after completing his medical studies at Harvard. He subsequently worked as a scientist at several institutions. In 1847 he became professor of anatomy and physiology at Harvard. In the following years, he founded a museum of anatomy. He became professor of American archeology and ethnology in 1866, and founded a museum of ethnology. His most famous anatomical studies include those of the gorilla, in particular the first decription of this species.


Note that Hanno described the gorilla in 470 BC, his written description survived 2200 years, yet Western science had yet to "discover" the species, despite the beginnings of Darwinism occurring at this precise time.
Huntster
Well, well; while researching Darwin, Savage, and Du Chaillu, I find this:

QUOTE
...Sarkis Atamian's book--The Origin of Tarzan : The Mystery of Tarzan's Creation Solved--Publication Consultants; ISBN: 1888125128; (December 1998)--suggested Du Chaillu's African books might be the source for Edgar Rice Burroughs' inspiration of the famous ape-man: Tarzan of the Apes....


Sarkis is a friend of mine. If he has already studied Du Chaillu extensively, he may have some insight that may be intersting. An accomplished professor and big game hunter, he may also have some thoughts on sasquatchery that I wasn't aware of.

I hope I can catch him soon.
Huntster
Unfortunately, I received word this evening that Sarkis Atamian passed away today.

This was a great man, and the loss to all who knew him is beyond my power to describe.

Armenian resistance fighter, writer, author, U.S. Army soldier, psychology professor, Big game hunter, husband, father, and friend, his spirit, wisdom, and intelligence will be sorely missed.

Any knowledge of Paul DuChaillu and the discovery of the gorilla not published in "The Origins of Tarzan" is now lost forever.
HuntFish
Sorry to hear about your friend. He seemed to be a very interesting person.

I've always been fascinated about the Gorilla. I've often wondered what it was like for the people who first discussed the creature without any evidence to back them up. Did they take a lot of flak from the scientist or people of that time for what they claimed to have seen in the wilds of Africa?
I've also wondered about what caliber rifles that were used to down the animal.
Once the animal was recognize as a new species, what happened to the gorilla population after every museum and scientific organization wanted one for their collection?

Maybe when I find time to read up on the subject, I can answer all those questions. Du Chiallu seems like a good place to start though.

Again... sorry for the loss of your friend.
Huntster
Thanks for your kind words.

I've googled DuChaillu, but the best site I came up with was a sort of promo for Sarkis's book.

Another interesting person in the discovery was Reverend Thomas Savage, a missionary who brought gorilla skulls to some scientists in 1847.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.